INSTITUTE OF PHYSICS PUBLISHING MEASUREMENT SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY Meas. Sci. Technol. 16 (2005) 548–555 doi:10.1088/0957-0233/16/2/030 An ultrasonic air temperature measurement system with self-correction function for humidity Wen-Yuan Tsai1,2, Hsin-Chieh Chen1 and Teh-Lu Liao1 1 Department of Engineering Science, National Cheng Kung University, Tainan, 701 Taiwan, Republic of China 2 Department of Electrical Engineering, Kao Yuan Institute of Technology, Kaohsiung, 821 Taiwan, Republic of China E-mail: [email protected] Received 15 June 2004, in final form 20 October 2004 Published 21 January 2005 Online at stacks.iop.org/MST/16/548 Abstract This paper proposes an ultrasonic measurement system for air temperature with high accuracy and instant response. It can measure the average temperature of the environmental air by detecting the changes of the speed of the ultrasound in the air. The changes of speed of sound are computed from combining variations of time-of-flight (TOF) from a binary frequency shift-keyed (BFSK) ultrasonic signal and phase shift from continuous waves [11]. In addition, another proposed technique for the ultrasonic air temperature measurement is the self-correction functionality within a highly humid environment. It utilizes a relative humidity/water vapour sensor and applies the theory of how sound speed changes in a humid environment. The proposed new ultrasonic air temperature measurement has the capability of self-correction for the environment variable of humidity. Especially under the operational environment with high fluctuations of various humidity levels, the proposed system can accurately self-correct the errors on the conventional ultrasonic thermometer caused by the changing density of the vapours in the air. Including the high humidity effect, a proof-of-concept experiment demonstrates that in dry air (relative humidity, RH = 10%) without humidity correction, it is accurate to ±0.4 ◦ C from 0 ◦ C to 80 ◦ C, while in highly humid air (relative humidity, RH = 90%) with self-correction functionality, it is accurate to ±0.3 ◦ C from 0 ◦ C to 80 ◦ C with 0.05% resolution and temperature changes are instantly reflected within 100 ms. Keywords: ultrasonic sensors, humidity sensors, temperature measurement 1. Introduction In many industrial processes, such as refining, roasting etc, the online control of temperature is often very important for saving energy, guaranteeing product quality and raising the productivity etc. Up to now, thermocouples and radiation thermometers have been the two main methods for measuring temperature in industry. Accurate and sensitive as the thermocouple is, it cannot work durably at high temperature and it is hard to realize online control. With the development 0957-0233/05/020548+08$30.00 of photoelectronic techniques, great improvements have been made in radiation thermometers. However, because of its susceptibility to fume and mist, accurate measurement is difficult to obtain in the above hostile environments. Over the past several decades, ultrasonic thermometry has been evolving as a new temperature measurement technology for environments where thermocouples, radiation pyrometers and other conventional instruments have failed to operate satisfactorily. Its principle is that the velocity of sound in any object is a function of temperature, so that, in an ideal gas, © 2005 IOP Publishing Ltd Printed in the UK 548 An ultrasonic air temperature measurement system with self-correction function for humidity the velocity is directly proportional to the square root of the absolute temperature, in most liquids the dependence is linear, and in solid objects the velocity generally decreases with the increment of the temperature. Thus, if the velocity of sound is measured, the temperature is measured [1]. Therefore, the high-speed ultrasonic thermometer is designed for measuring the temperature of high-temperature gas streams. The areas of application include the heat power industry, plasmatrons or other energy equipment, the chemical industry, development and research of jet engines, etc. The major advantages of the ultrasonic thermometer are its high operating speed, reaching 1500 measurements per second, and complete automation of measuring process [2]. Others have explored an ultrasonic method of sensing cabin air temperature that could lead to automatic climate control (ACC) with improved thermal comfort. Perceived thermal comfort is better correlated with breath-level temperature than it is with the output of the conventional in-car sensor. To sense bulk air temperature, a method was proposed transparent to the occupant—to send a pulse of ultrasound through the air [3, 4, 11]. The most common sensors for air temperature are usually sensor-by-contact. They rely on the sensors to contact the air and use its radiant energy to cause changes in their physical characteristics. This type of sensor usually does not respond instantly and their range of measurement is limited. Thus they are not ideal for dynamic tracking measurements of fast changing temperature. The speed of sound in gas has been widely explored. It is commonly understood that the speed of sound is affected by temperature, pressure, relative humidity and the constituents of the air [5]. The theoretical expression for the speed of sound c in an ideal gas is γP c= (1) ρ where P is the ambient pressure, ρ denotes the gas density and γ is the ratio of the specific heat of gas at constant pressure to that at constant volume. In an ideal gas, equation (1) may be rewritten as 1.4RT c= (2) M where R is the universal gas constant, T is the absolute temperature and M is the mean molecular weight of the air. √ From equation (2), we know c is proportional to T . That is why the techniques of measuring the temperature of air on the propagation path by sound speed are widely adopted [6, 7]. All previous discussion assumed dry air. However, moisture affects the speed of sound by changing the density of the air and the mean molecular weight, as shown in equations (1) and (2). Moist air is less dense than dry air (not particularly obvious), so ρ in equation (1) gets smaller. This causes an increase in the speed of sound. Moisture also causes the specific-heat ratio to decrease, which would cause the speed of sound to decrease. However, the decrease in density dominates, so the speed of sound increases with increasing moisture. In this paper, we propose an ultrasonic air temperature measurement system with self-correction for humidity. Furthermore, it is a contactless sensor and has an instant response. 2. Correction for humidity Two terms in equation (2) must be modified to accurately include the effects of moisture (water vapour) on the speed of sound. These are the specific-heat ratio γ (1.4 for dry air) and M, the average molecular weight of the different types of molecules in the air. Development of each of these terms follows [8–10]. The terms R (universal gas constant) and T (absolute temperature) remain unchanged. The specific-heat ratio can be expressed as an exact fraction by letting d equal the number of degrees of freedom for the air molecules. This gives d +2 γ = . (3) d Since the composition of dry air is mostly two atom molecules, it is said to be a diatomic gas. Diatomic gases have five degrees of freedom, three translational and two rotational; thus d = 5 and γ = 1.4, for dry air. If h is defined to be equal to the fraction of molecules that are water, then the presence of water (with six degrees of freedom) causes the average number of degrees of freedom per molecule to increase to 5 + h. Equation (3) can now be rewritten to include the effects of moisture for air as 7+h γw = . (4) 5+h It is noted that equation (4) is an alternative but equivalent expression to Humphreys’ equation as used in thermodynamics [8]. The average molecular weight of air decreases with added moisture. To see this, M is calculated first for dry air. Dry air composition is • 78% nitrogen (molecular weight = 28) • 21% oxygen (molecular weight = 32) • 1% argon (molecular weight = 40) for a total molecular weight equal to M = (0.78)(28) + (0.21)(32) + (0.01)(40) = 29. The presence of water (with a molecular weight of 18) causes the total average molecular weight to decrease to 29 − (29 − 18)h, or Mw = 29 − 11h. (5) Equations (4) and (5) modify the two terms from equation (2) affected by the addition of water vapour to air. Both are a function of the introduced water molecule fraction h. Relative humidity RH (expressed as a percentage) is defined such that 0.01RH e(T ) h= (6) p where p equals ambient pressure (1.013 × 105 Pa for 1 atm reference pressure) and e(T ) is the vapour pressure of water at temperature T . For temperature values in degrees Celsius, representative values of e(T ) are e(5) = 872 Pa e(10) = 1228 Pa e(15) = 1705 Pa e(20) = 2338 Pa e(30) = 4243 Pa e(40) = 7376 Pa. To express the percentage increase in the speed of sound due to relative humidity all that remains is to take the ratio of the 549 W-Y Tsai et al T[deg C] CHANGE IN VELOCITY (%) 1.2 Thermocouple e-Readout T=40 1.1 To PC 1.0 0.9 0.8 Receiver 0.7 Transmitter T=30 0.6 Temperature/Humidity Control Chamber 0.5 0.4 T=20 0.3 T=15 T=10 T=5 0.2 0.1 0.0 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 Preamplifier and Gain-Controlled Amplifier Transmitted Signal Source Power Amplifier 89c51 Single Chip Microprocessor LCD 100 RELATIVE HUMIDITY IN PERCENT (RH%) Figure 1. Relative humidity versus percentage change in speed of sound as a function of temperature. wet and dry speeds, subtract 1, and multiply by 100. Since both wet and dry speed terms involve the same constant terms (R and T), their ratio will cause these to cancel, giving the increase in sound speed c(%) √ cw γw RT /Mw c(%) = − 1 × 100 = √ − 1 × 100 cd γd RT /Md γw = 455.13 − 100. (7) Mw Equation (7) is plotted in figure 1 as a function of relative humidity for six temperature values. Figure 1 shows the percentage increase in the sound speed due to relative humidity only; the temperature values are for accurately specifying the relative humidity. RS232 Frequency Detector To accurately measure the temperature of the environmental air, we use the effect of humidity on the speed of sound stated above and combine the technique of transmit/receipt ultrasonic signals of binary frequency shift-keyed (BFSK) and continuous waves and obtain the average air temperature from the data of time-of-flight (TOF) and phase shift (PS) [11– 13]. The ultrasonic sensor system for temperature is shown in figure 2. An ultrasonic transmitter is installed on the righthand side of the temperature/humidity-controlled chamber, the receiver is on the left-hand side. The distance between the transmitter and receiver is 100 cm so that the average of the environmental air temperature can be measured. 3.1. TOF calculation In figure 3, the elapsed time t, which is the travel time of the signal from the transmitter to the receiver, can be calculated as t = t2 − t1 where t1 is the time when the transmitted signal changes frequency from f1 to f2 , and t2 is the time when the corresponding received signal changes frequency from f1 to f2 . The speed of sound can be expressed by c = L/t, where L is the distance between the transmitter transducer and receiver transducer. Digital Phase Meter 40/42kHz continuous wave PC Detection & Calibration Figure 2. Block diagram of the ultrasonic temperature measurement system. Amplitude ∆t t1 t2 t 0 f1 f2 Transmitted signals f1 f2 Received signals Figure 3. Transmitted signals and received signals. 3. Ultrasonic measurement of temperature 550 Relative Humidity/ Water Vapor Pressure e-Readout T1 f1 Transmitted signals Received signals θ1 f1 T2 θ2 f2 f2 Figure 4. Illustration of the phase shifts θ1 and θ2 . 3.2. Phase shift detection The detection of the phase shift is based on the two-frequency continuous wave method of ultrasonic distance measurement [12]. The phase shifts of θ1 and θ2 can be detected by the received signals corresponding to the transmitted signals. Figure 4 shows a continuous wave with frequency f1 and a received signal with frequencies f1 and f2 . Phase shift θ1 is the difference in phase between the continuous wave and the received signal at f1 . Phase shift θ1 can be calculated as θ1 = 2π(t2 − t1 )/T1 , where T1 is the period of the received signal with frequency f1 . Similarly, phase shift θ2 is the difference in phase between the continuous wave and the received signal at frequencyf2 . The following will calculate An ultrasonic air temperature measurement system with self-correction function for humidity ∆θ λ 2π(6.28) #n π(3.14) 0 0.5 1 n-2 n-1 n n+1 Distance L Figure 5. Relation between L = c × t and L = (n − 1) × λ + (θ/2π ) × λ. the speed of sound by comparing the two phase shifts. Note that the distance between the transmitter transducer and receiver transducer remains unchanged. We have θ1 c L = n1 + (8) × 2π f1 θ2 c L = n2 + × . 2π f2 (9) Here Lis the distance between the two transducers, n1 and n2 are integers. Due to the difference in frequencies, the phase shift can be deduced from (8) and (9) as follows: f θ = 2π × L × (f = f1 − f2 ). (10) c The integers n have only two possible values: n1 = n2 and n1 = n2 + 1. So the difference of the phase shifts can be defined by the following algorithm: Figure 6. Block diagram of the transmitted signal source. From equation (2) we know the temperature in degrees Celsius is c 2 −1 . (13) T = 273.15 × 331.45 This equation does not consider the variable of humidity. From equation (7) we know the sound speed increase due to humidity increase is c. So to include the effect of humidity on the sound speed, the sound speed equation would become cc = c × 1 . 1 + c The calculation for temperature would become cc 2 Tc = 273.15 × −1 331.45 (14) (15) where cc is the speed of sound with humidity effect correction and Tc is the temperature with humidity effect correction. 1. if θ1 > θ2 , θ = θ1 − θ2 , 2. if θ1 < θ2 , θ = θ1 + 2π − θ2 . Hence 4. System implementation c= θ 2π L × 1 f (11) . The variation of the ultrasonic velocity can be uniquely determined by the difference of the phase shifts (θ) if the maximum variation does not exceed one period of the frequency difference (f ). Otherwise phase ambiguity will occur. The minimum resolution and the maximum range of the temperature measurement are determined by the choice of frequencies (f1 , f2 ). 3.3. Temperature calculation The distance L can be expressed as L = c × t where t is TOF. In figure 5, the distance L is divided into regions [(n − 1)λ, nλ] (n = 1, 2, 3, . . .), λ is the wavelength of fc . × f The distance L can be expressed as L = (n − 1) + θ 2π where n is an integer. The region defined by [(n − 1)λ, nλ] is called #n region. The n − 1 integer can be obtained by an integer operation Int(t × f ). The speed of sound can then be expressed as c= L Int(t × f ) + θ 2π × 1 f . (12) Figure 2 is a block diagram of the complete system which consists of a temperature/humidity-controlled chamber, a thermocouple-based thermometer, a relative humidity/water vapour pressure meter, two acoustic transducers with matching exponential horns, a signal generation system, power amplifier, preamplifier and gain-controlled system, frequency detector and digital phase meter. The thermocouple is used to measure the air temperature and compare the measurement with the output of the ultrasonic system. A microprocessor controls the operation of the entire system and a PC will examine the measurement result and perform calibration. 4.1. Hardware 4.1.1. Transmitted signal source. The transmitted pulse is made up of two sinusoids (40 and 42 kHz). Figure 6 shows a crystal oscillator circuit used to generate a steady signal with a base frequency of 80 MHz. The divisors of two dividers are set at 2000 and 1904 which is applied to the base frequency. Two frequencies 40 kHz and 42 kHz are then produced and sent to the multiplexer (MUX). The MUX is controlled by an 89c51 microprocessor. 551 W-Y Tsai et al Figure 7. Block diagram of the frequency detector. The thermocouple voltage is converted into a temperature reading with a Testo 946 thermometer. The accuracy in the specification of this instrument is said to be ±0.2 ◦ C. We use an ice–water bath to check the accuracy. The difference from the actual temperature at 0 ◦ C was + 0.1 ◦ C within the claimed accuracy. The output of the thermometer is sent to a PC used as the standard temperature. The measurement of the relative humidity/water vapour pressure meter is by Sable System RH-200 meter (accuracy±1%). Therefore, the PC has t, the elapsed time of the ultrasound, phase shift data and the temperature measured by the thermocouple and the relative humidity/water vapour pressure measured by the gas sensor. From these data, the PC can calculate the errors of the temperature measurement and build up a calibration system. 4.2. Software Figure 8. Block diagram of the digital phase meter. 4.1.2. Preamplifier and gain-controlled amplifier. The bandwidth of the ultrasonic transducers used in our system is narrow. To reduce error from acoustic attenuation, the gain of the amplifier must dynamically adjust as the frequency of the ultrasound changes. Therefore, the error incurred from acoustic attenuation is minimized in the gaincontrolled amplifier by keeping the received signal amplitude dynamically constant. 4.1.3. Frequency detector. Figure 7 shows the block diagram of the frequency detector. The frequency detector detects the time when the frequency of the received signal changes from f1 (40 kHz) to f2 (42 kHz). The detected time is then used by the microprocessor to calculate TOF. 4.1.4. Digital phase meter. The phase shift is transformed into pulse width by two D-type flip-flops, as shown in figure 8. An 80 MHz signal is used to count the pulse width. The resolution of the phase metre is 0.05% for a 40 kHz signal. Finally, the counter is cleared by a reset signal generated by the microprocessor for counting the next phase shift. 4.1.5. 89c51 single-chip microprocessor. The measurement system is controlled by an 89c51 single-chip microprocessor (Atmel, made in USA). The functions of the microprocessor include controlling the BFSK signals of the ultrasound, obtaining the digital phase shift and humidity/vapour pressure data, calculating the TOF and the air temperature and displaying it. 4.1.6. Calibration system. As shown in figure 2, a chamber with constant temperature/humidity inside has an internal fan to maintain the inside air temperature/humidity uniform. A thermocouple measures the air temperature inside the chamber. 552 The algorithm of the software program in the microprocessor can be explicated by the flowchart shown in figure 9. First, the 89c51 microprocessor will fetch the actual temperature T1 measured by the thermocouple and the relative humidity/water vapour pressure meter measured by the sensor from the PC. Next, it will calculate the increase in sound speed due to the increased humidity c, assign the transmitted signal, adjust the gain-controlled amplifier, wait for the interrupt from either the frequency detector or the digital phase metre to calculate the TOF, obtain θ1 and θ2 and calculate the corrected speed of sound cc and the temperature T2 . Then, it will compare T1 with T2 . If |T2 − T1 | < 1 ◦ C, it will display T2 on the LCD. Otherwise, the PC will recalculate according to the temperature data and humidity variables from the calibration system. If the waiting time is longer than 50 ms, 89c51 will reassign the transmitted signal. TOF, θ1 , θ2 , c and cc are all sent to the PC via the RS232 interface of the 89c51. 5. Experimental results and discussions 5.1. Ultrasonic experiment To collect data, we first measure the air temperature and humidity/vapour pressure in the chamber with the thermocouple and gas sensor. Secondly, three times we record the TOF of the BFSK ultrasonic pulse in the chamber, the θ1 and θ2 from continuous waves. Then, we measure the air temperature and humidity/vapour pressure with the thermocouple and gas sensor for a second time. Finally, we compare the average of the three TOF, θ1 and θ2 measurements with the average of the two thermocouple measurements. Both can represent the air temperature at the same point of time, i.e. halfway through the measurement cycle. From 0 ◦ C to 80 ◦ C with 1 ◦ C as the interval, we will repeat the measurement and record the data at different temperatures. Using this measurement system and calculating the speed of sound with equation (12), we can obtain the average temperature of the air on the propagation path. 5.2. Experimental results Figure 10 shows, from 0 ◦ C to 80 ◦ C, the data diagram of the temperature measured by the ultrasonic thermometer without humidity correction and the actual temperature measured An ultrasonic air temperature measurement system with self-correction function for humidity Figure 9. The flowchart of the software. 0.4 Error Temperature [deg C] Ultrasonic Temperature [deg C] 80 60 40 20 0.2 0.0 -0.2 -0.4 0 0 20 40 60 80 0 20 40 60 Thermocouple Temperature [deg C] Thermocouple Temperature [deg C] (a ) (b) 80 Figure 10. (a) At relative humidity = 10%, without humidity correction, a logged data graph of the actual thermocouple temperature versus calculated ultrasonic temperature with humidity correction. (b) The plot of temperature error. by thermocouple, when the relative humidity RH of the environment is 10%. The maximum error is ±0.4 ◦ C. Figure 11(a) shows, from 0 ◦ C to 80 ◦ C, the data diagram of the temperature measured by the ultrasonic thermometer without humidity correction and the actual temperature measured by thermocouple, when the relative humidity RH of the environment is 90%. From the diagram, we can observe that the temperature measured by the ultrasonic 553 80 130 120 110 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Ultrasonic Temperature [deg C] Ultrasonic Temperature [deg C] W-Y Tsai et al 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Thermocouple Temperature [deg C] 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 0 80 80 (a) (a ) 45 0.3 Error Temperature [deg C] Error Temperature [deg C] 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Thermocouple Temperature [deg C] 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0.2 0.1 0.0 -0.1 -0.2 -0.3 0 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Thermocouple Temperature [deg C] 80 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Thermocouple Temperature [deg C] 80 (b ) (b ) Figure 11. (a) At relative humidity = 90%, without humidity correction, a logged data graph of the actual thermocouple temperature versus calculated ultrasonic temperature without humidity correction. (b) The plot of temperature error. Figure 12. (a) At relative humidity = 90%, with humidity correction, a logged data graph of the actual thermocouple temperature versus calculated ultrasonic temperature with humidity correction. (b) The plot of temperature error. thermometer is far higher than the actual temperature because of the humidity effect. The errors are shown in figure 11(b). As the temperature rises, the error increases. When the actual temperature is 80 ◦ C, the temperature measured by the ultrasonic thermometer without humidity correction is an astounding 124.8 ◦ C. The reason for this large error is that the relative humidity in the environment caused an increase in the speed of sound. Figure 12(a) shows the data diagram of the temperature measured by ultrasonic thermometer with humidity correction and the actual temperature measured by thermocouple, when the relative humidity RH of the environment remains 90%. Figure 12(b) shows the errors between these two measured temperatures. The standard error of measurement is calculated as follows: n [RP (i) − P P ]2 SE = (16) n i 5.3. Discussions where RP is the temperature of the ultrasonic measurement, P P is the temperature measured by thermocouple, n is the number of measurements. The average error is 0.19 ◦ C and the standard error is 0.24 ◦ C. Through repeated experiments, if the temperature is under 80 ◦ C, the difference between the ultrasonic measurement and the actual temperature consistently remains within ±0.3 ◦ C. 554 We have established a new ultrasonic air thermometer with the function of humidity correction. Our system successfully combines the techniques of TOF, PS and humidity sensor. With the transmission of BFSK signals, upon receiving the ultrasonic pulse, the TOF is readily calculated by the time the change between each discrete frequency occurs. To achieve higher accuracy, continuous wave transmission is used to calculate the phase shift between the transmitting and receiving signals. Phase shift operation offers a special advantage by eliminating a class of attenuation problems that often accompany short-burst transmissions which go through nonlinear signal distortion during start up as a result of transmitting transducer mechanical spring coefficients producing audio signals with slow-onset envelopes. The slow onset makes the exact signal start time unclear to the receiver. Continuous wave transmission has similar start/stop envelope problems. But during continuous operation these problems are gone. With the help of a humidity sensor, the error caused by environmental humidity is effectively corrected in our ultrasonic thermometer system. From the experiments, the error between the actual temperature measured by thermocouple and the temperature measured by our system is only ±0.3 ◦ C. This is the result An ultrasonic air temperature measurement system with self-correction function for humidity when the system repeats the measurement every 0.1 s. This level of accuracy with the speed of ultrasonic system detection is more than adequate for average temperature control systems. References [1] Mi X B, Zhang S Y, Zhang J J and Yang Y T 2003 Automatic ultrasonic thermometry Paper presented at 15th Symp. on Thermophysical Properties (Boulder, CO, June 22–27) [2] Butkus J and Jakevicius L 2001 Investigation of stability of ultrasonic system for gas flow velocity measurement Ultragarsas 40 no 3 36 [3] Han T, Lambert D, Oberdier L, Partin D and Sultan M 2003 Ultrasonic air temperature sensing for automatic climate control-sensor development SAE Paper 2003-01-0740 (SAE World Congress, Detroit) [4] Han T, Lambert D, Oberdier L, Partin D and Sultan M 2004 Ultrasonic air temperature sensing for automatic climate control-vehicle test SAE Paper 2004-01-1375 (SAE World Congress, Detroit) [5] Wong G S K 1986 Speed of sound in standard air J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 79 1359–66 [6] Bramanti M, Salerno E A, Tonazzini A, Pasini S and Gray A 1996 An acoustic pyrometer system for tomographic thermal imaging in power plant boilers IEEE Trans. Instrum. Meas. 45 159–67 [7] Huang K N, Huang C F and Li Y C 2002 High precision, fast ultrasonic thermometer based on measurement of the speed of sound in air Rev. Sci. Instrum. 73 4022–7 [8] CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics 1986 67th edn (Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press) [9] Pierce A D 1981 Acoustics: An Introduction to its Physical Principles and Applications (New York: McGraw-Hill) [10] Dennis A B 1988 Environmental effects on the speed of sound J. Audio Eng. Soc. 36 8690–710 [11] Liao T L, Tsai W Y and Huang C F 2004 A new ultrasonic temperature measurement system for air conditioners in automobiles Meas. Sci. Technol. 15 413–9 [12] Gueuning F E, Varlan M, Eugene C E and Dupuis P 1997 Accurate distance measurement by an autonomous ultrasonic system combining time-of-flight and phase-shift methods IEEE Trans. Instrum. Meas. 46 1236–40 [13] Huang S S, Huang C F and Huang K N 2002 A high accuracy ultrasonic distance measurement system using binary frequency shift-keyed signal and phase detection Rev. Sci. Instrum. 73 3671–7 555
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz